chapter
CAN YOU DENY MIRACLES OR SUPERNATURAL REPORTED BY THE CHOSEN PEOPLE?
argument

176. PRACTICAL REQUIREMENTS

Jewish tradition is not just a matter of faith and memory. It imposes on the People of Israel a long list of commandments and requirements, some of which are demanding and not easy to implement in the people’s daily life. The Torah imposes severe restrictions on the realm of sexuality and marriage; reduces the types of food and animals that they are allowed to eat; establishes a system of laws of impurity and purity; demands the giving of gifts to the poor, priests, and Levites and describes the necessary offering of sacrifices to the temple; and in general imposes commandments and prohibitions on man in all spheres of life.

The existence of a system of practical requirements strengthens the belief in tradition in two ways: First, if humans invented the Torah, it is not clear what interest they have in inventing all the commandments contained in it. As is well known, the commandments of the Torah also limit the power of the king (prohibition of multiplying horses, women and treasures), of the priests (they have no land), and of the rich (omission of duties every 7 years and restitution of land every jubilee). If the Torah was concocted by people of the same classes, why would these individuals then want to limit themselves in how they could live and enjoy their lives?

And second, it is clear that it is much more difficult to convince people of the truth of a tradition when belief in it requires from them practical and severe demands in all spheres of their lives. It is relatively easy to convince people of some miraculous story when there are no practical implications derived from it; it is much harder to convince people of a story that imposes restrictions on all lifestyles. If the children of Israel nevertheless accepted the Torah, it is evidence that the status of Mount Sinai did occur and is engraved in their memory as passed down from the ages.

Although a system of commandments has existed in other peoples as well, we must remember that Biblical law differs in some crucial points from the laws and commandments of other peoples. The observance of the commandments stems solely from the historical tradition about the Exodus from Egypt and the giving of the Torah at Sinai, and for that reason, there is a close connection between persuading the people in the story to accept the yoke of the commandments.

For other nations, the commandments do not necessarily depend on the existence of miracles, and therefore it is much easier to assimilate them. In addition, Biblical law encompasses all areas of life and differs in many essential points from ancient law. In the ancient world, sacrificing children for example was a matter of routine, whereas commandments such as Shabbat or Shemita (sabbatical year or Sabbath of The Land) are completely different from those to which the ancients were accustomed. A system that requires the sacrifice of the believer’s economic base, and the considerable number of prohibitions such as foreign labor, are certainly to be considered a significant challenge to any person in the ancient Near East. The great difficulty of the children of Israel in disengaging from foreign labor and their many failures in this field testify to this ideology. Any significant change from the norm at that time is very difficult to “digest” by the people, making it even more difficult to accept the story. This fact also strengthens the credibility of the story told to the People of Israel.

"The Logical Proof Of GOD" book by HOLY LAND MAN

More Posts

YOUR SOUL NEEDS SPIRITUALITY BUT YOU ONLY TRUST REALITY & FACTS

In the spiritual world reside the forces that operate our lives in daily reality. Get to know them, because your happiness depends on them.

While we are selfish creatures with survival mechanisms and animal instincts to achieve more than we need, we’re also wired (DNA & neurotheology) for spirituality and to live for the greater good, for the higher self. For that reason, we are wired to protect our spouse, our family, our country, and be connected to a higher spirituality we call GOD (whatever it is).

We seek to connect to the highest authority which is above human sensual perception. We seek a GOD to be our ultimate guide. Not the GOD that the religions created for us with endless restrictions and imaginary hell and heaven, but the true real GOD.

This book sums up thousands of years and debates to one practical conclusion: is it good for humans to have and believe in (a) GOD or not.

While emerging in the debate, keep an open mind and ignore any religious misconception of who GOD really is. You are here because you care to know if there is a higher authority and if your life will be more fulfilled with GOD in it. You want to know if spirituality is good for you.

WHEN DO YOU FEEL SPIRITUALITY?

The spirit is invisible, but it is revealed in every phenomenon in life that means oneness. It is revealed the moment you look into a person’s eyes and discover that you both feel the same. Spirituality is revealed as soon as you do something that makes others a caravan of joy. It is revealed the moment someone refers to you and you refer to him, and you are both aware of each other’s existence. As a Roman poet so beautifully put it: “Outside all the notions of good and evil there is a field. Will you meet me there?”

Socrates was said to have not come from Athens, but from the world. You and I are two aspects of one reality, united and all-embracing. In unity no differences are eliminated. For things to unite, they do not have to lose their individual identities.  In unity only the separation between them is abolished, which is the difference in value and importance. Then it turns out that everything is one thing.

Share on Social Media